ThePortForum.com

Tom provided four excellent bottles, all from Hedges & Butler (which I guessed): Fd63, D55, D63, T60. And a half bottle of Mouton Rothschild 1955, alas not bottled by Hedges & Butler.

Links:

• Review of the evening as a whole;
• 1963 Feuerheerd (Ⅰ);
• 1955 Dow (Ⅱ);
• 1963 Dow (Ⅲ);
• 1960 Taylor (Ⅳ);
• 1955 Mouton Rothschild (Ⅴ);
• Placemats (and parameters by which made);
• Planning and arrangements.

A wonderful selection of ports with the Feuerheerd 1963 showing magnificently. But my wine of the night by a clear margin was the fabulous Mouton 1955.

Sounds, and looks, like a fine evening's drinking.

Yes, does sound like a good affair-unfortunately, two passes in three days proved beyond my means!

Brilliant evening I stumbled into after attending some leaving drinks. WON was the Mouton 55 in front of the Feuerheerd 63

regards

WS1

which I guessed

Eventually....

uncle tom wrote:Eventually....

You mean that our first guesses were wrong, and so were our subsequent guesses, and a few after that, and so you said we had to keep guessing until we got it. And I got it. I was right.

Or something.

Crosses absent because I used the wrong voting page. Doh! And I mis-dated the placemats with 27^th rather than 28^th. Doh doh!!

Humble thanks to Tom who really rose to the challenge of a theme which was thrown out as an impossibility - four bottle of port from the same UK bottler. And not only did Tom manage the challenge, he also added the twist that although there were four bottles there were only three shippers and three vintages represented. Served blind, we were as good as usual in managing to identify shipper and vintage. Wolfgang and Julian tied in first place with 2 points (out of a possible 10) and I came third with 1 point.

Thank you Tom, for a fabulous tasting - and especially for the bonus and unexpected half bottle of Mouton '55.

+1 to the previous post.