We decided to get our act together for a fellow tpf taster from paris.
Wines in attendance
SW 76 Colheita
SW 80 VP
SW 83 VP
SW 84 LBV
SW 85 VO
SW 95 Madalena
SW 95 LBV
Wa 63 VP
F 75 VP
I am sorry to say that the Fonseca 75 was the wine of the night fo rme.
I originally had the SW 80 and 83 rated very highly however once teh fonseca came out, they were both dropped by at least a level of complexity.
Still, some good ports, but the price is rightly so as the SW is unfortunately no first rate.
Jan 8th, tasting in ny in honor of jdaw
Jan 8th, tasting in ny in honor of jdaw
Last edited by g-man on 00:20 Mon 10 Jan 2011, edited 1 time in total.
Disclosure: Distributor of Quevedo wines and Quinta do Gomariz
-
JacobH
- Quinta do Vesuvio 1994
- Posts: 3300
- Joined: 16:37 Sat 03 May 2008
- Location: London, UK
- Contact:
Re: Jan 8th, tasting in ny in honor of jdaw
I’m glad to see our NYC friends continuing our efforts to re-educate jdaw1 on the merits of the ’75 vintage!g-man wrote:I am sorry to say that the Fonseca 75 was the wine of the night fo rme.
Re: Jan 8th, tasting in ny in honor of jdaw
hahaJacobH wrote:I’m glad to see our NYC friends continuing our efforts to re-educate jdaw1 on the merits of the ’75 vintage!g-man wrote:I am sorry to say that the Fonseca 75 was the wine of the night fo rme.
i must admit i agree wtih julian on most houses of the 75 vintage =)
Disclosure: Distributor of Quevedo wines and Quinta do Gomariz
Re: Jan 8th, tasting in ny in honor of jdaw
Links:
- Review of the event as a whole;
- 1976 Smith Woodhouse Colheita;
- 1980 Smith Woodhouse Vintage Port;
- 1983 Smith Woodhouse Vintage Port;
- 1984 Smith Woodhouse LBV;
- 1985 Smith Woodhouse Vintage Port;
- 1995 Smith Woodhouse Madalena SQVP;
- 1995 Smith Woodhouse LBV;
- 1963 Warre;
- 1975 Fonseca;
- Planning and arrangements.
Re: Jan 8th, tasting in ny in honor of jdaw
An excellent afternoon tasting was held at g-man towers in Floral Park, Long Island, NY. A particular commendation to the cooking: ham and pork, both extremely tender, and eaten in portions of proper size.
The primary theme was Smith Woodhouse, VP versus LBV, but a colheita joined the company. Smith Woodhouse is dark in colour but light in both nose and palate. The fruit is faint plum, but the overall sensation is of being mid- to under-weight.
My WOTN was SW85, despite the lightness. F75 made a very creditable showing, though suffering the same affliction. The W63 was freakishly pale (10% opacity!) it had faded into nothingness. I wonder whether the green bottle had allowed light damage?
The primary theme was Smith Woodhouse, VP versus LBV, but a colheita joined the company. Smith Woodhouse is dark in colour but light in both nose and palate. The fruit is faint plum, but the overall sensation is of being mid- to under-weight.
My WOTN was SW85, despite the lightness. F75 made a very creditable showing, though suffering the same affliction. The W63 was freakishly pale (10% opacity!) it had faded into nothingness. I wonder whether the green bottle had allowed light damage?
Re: Jan 8th, tasting in ny in honor of jdaw
In the next two pictures note the paleness of the SW84LBV, and the darkness of the VPs and other LBVs.
