At Bonham’s on 18 February 2016 was sold most of a pipe of Fonseca 1963, not moved since original purchase (lots 324 to 343).
So, on Wednesday 15th June 2016, we gathered in the Boot & Flogger to compare six of these, which were joined by a selection of other English-bottled Vintage Ports.
One of the 36 bottles sourced from the pipe sold at Bonhams in February 2016, which had been bottled and stored under identical conditions. 6 bottles with the same fill (top shoulder) were opened and tasted together to investigate the extent of bottle variation in mature port.
Bottle 6: Subdued on the nose, but clearly suffering from bottle stink - a smell which faded over the 90 minutes the wine sat in the glass. Gentle fruit flavours come through on the entry, fruit which has been baked or perhaps even toasted. The fruit flavours grow well and fill the mid-palate with a lovely dryness to the core of the wine, although the whole is slightly dirty. The aftertaste is dry and shows smokey tannins which hold a good grip on the very long finish. 86/100. 15-Jun-16. Decanted 3½ hours.
Top 2025: Quevedo 1972 Colheita, b.2024. Just as good as Niepoort 1900!
2026: DR Very Old White, Graham Stone Terraces 2011, Quevedo Branco 1986 b.2026