Page 1 of 1

Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 14:49 Thu 11 Jul 2013
by jdaw1
The BBC, in a long article entitled [url=http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23008300]English wine: Is sparkling wine better in England than France?[/url], wrote:The Duchess of Cornwall has called for a new name for English sparkling wine to match the grandeur of champagne. And for the first time, domestic wine is the most popular in the government's cellar. Have Britons developed a taste for a home-grown tipple?

Someone arrives with a bottle of English wine. Cue excitable voices saying, "Gosh, English wine is really quite good, you know - it gives champagne a run for its money."

The surprise used to be palpable.

But English wine has grown up. Today it regularly wins awards - there were four gold medals at the International Wine Challenge (IWC) this year.

!
Further down is mention of ‟Christian Seely”.

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 17:23 Thu 11 Jul 2013
by benread
But what would that name be?

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 21:30 Thu 11 Jul 2013
by DRT
Perhaps it could be called Wessex?

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 21:34 Thu 11 Jul 2013
by jdaw1
DRT wrote:Perhaps it could be called Wessex?
That’s good. Though accuracy might require a demarcated area called ‟Wessex and Kent”. Yes, the three-wordedness would be more distinctive.

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 08:16 Fri 12 Jul 2013
by Alex Bridgeman
jdaw1 wrote:
DRT wrote:Perhaps it could be called Wessex?
That’s good. Though accuracy might require a demarcated area called ‟Wessex and Kent”. Yes, the three-wordedness would be more distinctive.
WAK Wine does have a certain distinctiveness to it.

What does Christian Seely call his sparkling wine?

But I rather like the "does what it says on the tin" approach to call English sparkling wine "English sparkling wine". We don't need a fancy name to sell our product or a long history that we can use to sell devalued rubbish to ignorant consumers. English sparkling wine has to be good stuff if it is going to sell!

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 11:54 Fri 12 Jul 2013
by PhilW
AHB wrote:
jdaw1 wrote:
DRT wrote:Perhaps it could be called Wessex?
That’s good. Though accuracy might require a demarcated area called ‟Wessex and Kent”. Yes, the three-wordedness would be more distinctive.
WAK Wine does have a certain distinctiveness to it.
Good job it's not just North Kent.
But I rather like the "does what it says on the tin" approach to call English sparkling wine "English sparkling wine". We don't need a fancy name to sell our product or a long history that we can use to sell devalued rubbish to ignorant consumers. English sparkling wine has to be good stuff if it is going to sell!
Wessex, or WES could be an acronym for Wine, English, Sparling...

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 12:07 Fri 12 Jul 2013
by jdaw1
AHB wrote:What does Christian Seely call his sparkling wine?
The BBC, in a long article entitled [url=http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23008300]English wine: Is sparkling wine better in England than France?[/url], wrote:! The owners of Coates and Seely vineyard in the North Hampshire Downs have pushed the "Britagne" badge for sparkling wine.

"It is a brand which belongs to Coates and Seely, which we use for our own wine, and which we will invite other vineyards working closely with us to use," says Christian Seely. "It is definitely not intended as a generic term for all English sparkling wines." So Camilla's search for the right term goes on.

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 12:10 Fri 12 Jul 2013
by djewesbury
jdaw1 wrote:
AHB wrote:What does Christian Seely call his sparkling wine?
The BBC, in a long article entitled [url=http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23008300]English wine: Is sparkling wine better in England than France?[/url], wrote:! The owners of Coates and Seely vineyard in the North Hampshire Downs have pushed the "Britagne" badge for sparkling wine.

"It is a brand which belongs to Coates and Seely, which we use for our own wine, and which we will invite other vineyards working closely with us to use," says Christian Seely. "It is definitely not intended as a generic term for all English sparkling wines." So Camilla's search for the right term goes on.
I am against using a French word for English sparkling wine - it surely undermines the whole point!

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 12:19 Fri 12 Jul 2013
by jdaw1
AHB wrote:But I rather like the "does what it says on the tin" approach to call English sparkling wine "English sparkling wine". We don't need a fancy name to sell our product or a long history that we can use to sell devalued rubbish to ignorant consumers. English sparkling wine has to be good stuff if it is going to sell!
‟English sparkling wine”, or ‟English Sparkling Wine”?

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 13:33 Fri 12 Jul 2013
by PhilW
Any region-based word such as Wessex would naturally exclude English sparkling wine from other regions (such as East Anglia). Use of a non-regional word could presumably also be used by other nations, but this could be acceptable; consider "Diamond" as a term potentially used to indicate a high quality, highly sparkling wine; This could then be easily used in equivalent place of Champagne (by any country), as well as preceded by maker/brand. "Produce of <Country>", or "<Country> sparkling wine" could still be used in smaller lettering below, or <Country> Diamond (e.g. "English Diamond") used to clarify a specific country if wanted.

Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 13:35 Fri 12 Jul 2013
by djewesbury
PhilW wrote:Any region-based word such as Wessex would naturally exclude English sparkling wine from other regions (such as East Anglia). Use of a non-regional word could presumably also be used by other nations, but this could be acceptable; consider "Diamond" as a term potentially used to indicate a high quality, highly sparkling wine; This could then be easily used in equivalent place of Champagne (by any country), as well as preceded by maker/brand. "Produce of <Country>", or "<Country> sparkling wine" could still be used in smaller lettering below, or <Country> Diamond (e.g. "English Diamond") used to clarify a specific country if wanted.
Possibly sounds like high-strength cider?

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 17:51 Fri 12 Jul 2013
by DRT
I think it is appropriate to have a demarcated area marked out by stone pillars and managed by a state monopoly if the producers of this stuff want it to be thought of in the same bracket as other regionally (not country) based wines of the world. "English" just doesn't define it accurately enough in terms of terroir. In no time at all you would have cheap and nasty stuff on the market made with wines grown in the suburbs of Hull, Newcastle and Blackpool.

Why not call it "Tory"? That would keep all those northern scumbags away :lol:

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 13:24 Sat 13 Jul 2013
by PhilW
DRT wrote:I think it is appropriate to have a demarcated area marked out by stone pillars and managed by a state monopoly
Isn't that already called Stonehenge?

Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 13:38 Sat 13 Jul 2013
by djewesbury
PhilW wrote:
DRT wrote:I think it is appropriate to have a demarcated area marked out by stone pillars and managed by a state monopoly
Isn't that already called Stonehenge?
Perfect: The Stone Henges.

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 14:13 Sat 13 Jul 2013
by DRT
djewesbury wrote:
PhilW wrote:
DRT wrote:I think it is appropriate to have a demarcated area marked out by stone pillars and managed by a state monopoly
Isn't that already called Stonehenge?
Perfect: The Stone Henges.
But then people would think it was impossible to buy.

Re: Sparkling wine: England versus France

Posted: 14:43 Sat 13 Jul 2013
by djewesbury
DRT wrote:
djewesbury wrote:
PhilW wrote:
DRT wrote:I think it is appropriate to have a demarcated area marked out by stone pillars and managed by a state monopoly
Isn't that already called Stonehenge?
Perfect: The Stone Henges.
But then people would think it was impossible to buy.
I don't know what you mean, I've got my allocation :lol:
(Should be delivered some time around 2014....)