At Bonham’s on 18 February 2016 was sold most of a pipe of Fonseca 1963, not moved since original purchase (lots 324 to 343).
So, on Wednesday 15th June 2016, we gathered in the Boot & Flogger to compare six of these, which were joined by a selection of other English-bottled Vintage Ports.
One of the 36 bottles sourced from the pipe sold at Bonhams in February 2016, which had been bottled and stored under identical conditions. 6 bottles with the same fill (top shoulder) were opened and tasted together to investigate the extent of bottle variation in mature port.
Bottle 5: Attractive appearance, very similar to the other bottles being tasted. Foul on the nose, unpleasant; not clear whether the bottle was suffering severe bottle stink or a bacterial infection. 90 minutes later it was clear that it was bottle stink and it was fading, although a swirl brought it back with a vengeance! Sweet fruit on the palate, baked cherries and light tannins, tannins which take a gentle grip when the port is worked with air. Hot elastic bands on the late palate, which carry through to the aftertaste and finish, despite the gentle dry tannins. 82/100. 15-Jun-16. Decanted 3½ hours.
Top Ports in 2023: Taylor 1896 Colheita, b. 2021. A perfect Port.
2024: Niepoort 1900 Colheita, b.1971. A near perfect Port.