Different people give different weights to different criteria. From the outside, the ordering of these criteria is functionally equivalent to random. Therefore inviting people to vote as the ordering of their personal criteria direct would indeed generate a random result.AHB wrote:But aren't you missing the theme? This isn't a theme that says "Bring the bottle that most people vote for", it's "Bring a random bottle". You've selected a population, now choose a bottle at random.
Don’t believe me: behold DRT’s flailing around.
Source: you. Have you no more? If I do attend (which is unlikely), then of course. However, I will be at that cellar on Fri 29th Jan, and could collect it to be given to an attendee of the V vertical. Maybe this conversation should be held elsewhere.AHB wrote:But I would agree that the Vesuvio '92 would be a fine port to drink at the Vesuvio vertical - are you attending?
Depends on that other conversation.AHB wrote:If you are not attending on Feb 23 then leave the V92 in the population since it is unlikely that we will have a bottle of this vintage since no-one else has said they have one.