Still, you can sail all round it in reasonably substantial boats.. A man-made island is still an island (isn't that what John Donne said..?)Glenn E. wrote:Not a guess, but rather a side question/pedantic rant. I've never considered Manhattan to be an island - it is a peninsula that someone cut off by digging the Harlem River Ship Canal.djewesbury wrote:Glenn E. wrote:From Julian's link:
43 Manhattan Island United States (New York) 1,619,090 (2012)
Is a land mass really an island just because someone cut off the end of a peninsula with a canal?djewesbury wrote:The island in question is a small one and not on the list that Julian quoted.
After they moved London Bridge to the Chemehuevi Desert in AZ, the team of contractors worked to excavate a channel underneath it. This diverted a part of the stream of the Colorado River, and created an island at one end of the bridge. Just because it was the result of human intervention, it's still an island. If you can walk to it and not get your feet wet, perhaps it's not an island. By that reckoning, St. Michael's Mount is an island at high tide and a peninsular at low tide. That's reasonable, no..?
EDIT: they didn't really 'move' London Bridge; they built a concrete core and attached the facing stones from London Bridge to it. In fact there's so little rainfall there that you can still see the chalk markings they used to number the stones in transit. Yes, I made a film there...