- Arrangements;
- Blinded Placemats;
- Un-blinded Placemats;
- Review of the evening as a whole;
- 1980 Cockburn LBV;
- 1980 Dow;
- 1980 Ferreira;
- 1980 Fonseca (in Bottle);
- 1980 Fonseca (en Magnum);
- 1980 Graham’s;
- 1980 Hutcheson;
- 1980 Noval Nacional;
- 1980 Offley Boa Vista;
- 1980 Smith Woodhouse (in Bottle);
- 1980 Smith Woodhouse (in Halves)
- 1980 Taylor;
- 1980 Warre.
1980 Horizontal - Wokingham - 20 May 08
1980 Horizontal - Wokingham - 20 May 08
Links:
Last edited by DRT on 23:00 Thu 29 May 2008, edited 2 times in total.
"The first duty of Port is to be red"
Ernest H. Cockburn
Ernest H. Cockburn
Derek has now just had too much and can't take the pace. 14 bottles of port between six of us has proven too much for poor Derek. He has retired with reasonable fortitude having emptied all but one of his drinkable glasses.
Only Julian and I left now...
Alex B, taking advantage of Derek having left his PC on the tasting table
Only Julian and I left now...
Alex B, taking advantage of Derek having left his PC on the tasting table
"The first duty of Port is to be red"
Ernest H. Cockburn
Ernest H. Cockburn
-
- Quinta do Vesuvio 1994
- Posts: 3035
- Joined: 22:16 Mon 25 Jun 2007
- Location: Los Angeles, Ca USA
- Contact:
- RonnieRoots
- Fonseca 1980
- Posts: 1981
- Joined: 08:28 Thu 21 Jun 2007
- Location: Middle Earth
-
- Quinta do Vesuvio 1994
- Posts: 3035
- Joined: 22:16 Mon 25 Jun 2007
- Location: Los Angeles, Ca USA
- Contact:
Sorry about that team. Body-clock a bit muddled
Sorry about that team. Body-clock a bit muddled from the flight and drinking port until dawn.
- uncle tom
- Dalva Golden White Colheita 1952
- Posts: 3532
- Joined: 23:43 Wed 20 Jun 2007
- Location: Near Saffron Walden, England
I surfaced at around 6.30am, before taking an extra hour, but did have the advantage of spending some time comatose at the table. Julian surfaced at the crack of noon..
I have never previously been able to pin a specific 'signature' on the '80 vintage, and I'm not a lot the wiser now; but several of the wines had detectable traces of the higher alcohols (butanol?) - but not to the extent of being a major problem.
Winner of the night in my book was the Dow, although I talked myself into reckoning it was the Graham. (Some thought the best wine was the Ferreira)
Second on my list, and widely applauded was the Offley. Third was a Smith Woodhouse (from a bottle) Alex also included a decanter of SW drawn from two halves, which was much less impressive.
Warre and Graham also showed very well.
Worst wine of the night was a horribly pale and decaying Hutcheson.
Surprise of the night was the Nacional. It was the second palest wine of them all, and had me completely stumped as to its identity. My notes were confined to a single word 'coarse' It was not obviously faulty, but was in no way a premium wine.
Of the fourteeen decanters, I correctly identified four, one more than our efficient host, Alex B, and four more than someone who will remain nameless..!
Tom
I have never previously been able to pin a specific 'signature' on the '80 vintage, and I'm not a lot the wiser now; but several of the wines had detectable traces of the higher alcohols (butanol?) - but not to the extent of being a major problem.
Winner of the night in my book was the Dow, although I talked myself into reckoning it was the Graham. (Some thought the best wine was the Ferreira)
Second on my list, and widely applauded was the Offley. Third was a Smith Woodhouse (from a bottle) Alex also included a decanter of SW drawn from two halves, which was much less impressive.
Warre and Graham also showed very well.
Worst wine of the night was a horribly pale and decaying Hutcheson.
Surprise of the night was the Nacional. It was the second palest wine of them all, and had me completely stumped as to its identity. My notes were confined to a single word 'coarse' It was not obviously faulty, but was in no way a premium wine.
Of the fourteeen decanters, I correctly identified four, one more than our efficient host, Alex B, and four more than someone who will remain nameless..!
Tom
I may be drunk, Miss, but in the morning I shall be sober and you will still be ugly - W.S. Churchill
This paragraph is inaccurate.uncle tom wrote:Of the fourteeen decanters, I correctly identified four, one more than our efficient host, Alex B, and four more than someone who will remain nameless..!
Score me three: Fonseca magnum twice, and the Hutcheson, a bottle of which I had sampled less than a month before.
a big thank you to our excellent host.
First, and most important, a big thank you to our excellent host. Despite having multiple family commitments to handle, everything was organised, was to hand, and to hand in ample quantities. Great job Mr B.
Next I should praise the mathematics, and especially the division. “Fourteen bottles divided by six people is, err, about one and a quarter bottles each†, Derek T and I reassured each other. Derek even computed that a sixty-quid fillet for one person is about twenty-five quid a head. What could go wrong?
Next I should praise the mathematics, and especially the division. “Fourteen bottles divided by six people is, err, about one and a quarter bottles each†, Derek T and I reassured each other. Derek even computed that a sixty-quid fillet for one person is about twenty-five quid a head. What could go wrong?
Another fantastic off-line. A big thanks is due to AHB for his generous hospitality.
I was mightily releaved when Tom fell asleep at the table as I meant I wouldn't be first! I managed to be 4th to bed out of 6 which is possible a PB for me
Wine of the night for me was Dow followed by Graham and Taylor. Lots of other good showings, including the Offley, Ferreira, Warre and Smith Woodhouse.
The Nacional was disappointing. When I decanted it in the morning it was as hot as the fires of hell but this had blown off by evening. If there was any left it will be interesting to read AHB's follow-on TNs once it has had more air time. That said, it was a very light colour compared to the star performers on the night which suggests it is perhaps already going downhill.
I scored 1 out of 14 on the blind tasting. I got the Dow.
It was great to meet Axel for the first time and, as always, it was good fun spending time with the die-hards.
When's the next one?
Derek
I was mightily releaved when Tom fell asleep at the table as I meant I wouldn't be first! I managed to be 4th to bed out of 6 which is possible a PB for me
Wine of the night for me was Dow followed by Graham and Taylor. Lots of other good showings, including the Offley, Ferreira, Warre and Smith Woodhouse.
The Nacional was disappointing. When I decanted it in the morning it was as hot as the fires of hell but this had blown off by evening. If there was any left it will be interesting to read AHB's follow-on TNs once it has had more air time. That said, it was a very light colour compared to the star performers on the night which suggests it is perhaps already going downhill.
I scored 1 out of 14 on the blind tasting. I got the Dow.
It was great to meet Axel for the first time and, as always, it was good fun spending time with the die-hards.
When's the next one?
Derek
"The first duty of Port is to be red"
Ernest H. Cockburn
Ernest H. Cockburn
Re: a big thank you to our excellent host.
I just tried both of those divisions on my special calculator that i use to work out the true cost of port related purchases and both were entirely accurate.jdaw1 wrote:Next I should praise the mathematics, and especially the division. “Fourteen bottles divided by six people is, err, about one and a quarter bottles each†, Derek T and I reassured each other. Derek even computed that a sixty-quid fillet for one person is about twenty-five quid a head. What could go wrong?
"The first duty of Port is to be red"
Ernest H. Cockburn
Ernest H. Cockburn
- KillerB
- Taylor Quinta de Vargellas 1987
- Posts: 2425
- Joined: 22:09 Wed 20 Jun 2007
- Location: Sky Blue City, England
I got 1 1/2 as I called the Dow "Dow or Taylor".
Another shout out for the extravagantly good host and his genetically modified children. Organisation was immaculate and the fillet was a brilliant move. It should also be noted that six of us got through a 6lb box of mushrooms to go with the 6lb fillet of beef.
The Ports were surprisingly good for a non-stellar vintage and the OBV and Ferreira were especially surprising. Taylor, Fonseca and Nacional were all down the list for once with the Nacional a very long way down. Graham, Dow and Warre all stood up extremely well. Pleased about the Dow as some are heading my way, should be able to get more Warre. I will now be looking around for the Offley, which I thoroughly enjoyed.
Another shout out for the extravagantly good host and his genetically modified children. Organisation was immaculate and the fillet was a brilliant move. It should also be noted that six of us got through a 6lb box of mushrooms to go with the 6lb fillet of beef.
The Ports were surprisingly good for a non-stellar vintage and the OBV and Ferreira were especially surprising. Taylor, Fonseca and Nacional were all down the list for once with the Nacional a very long way down. Graham, Dow and Warre all stood up extremely well. Pleased about the Dow as some are heading my way, should be able to get more Warre. I will now be looking around for the Offley, which I thoroughly enjoyed.
Port is basically a red drink
Just to be clear, that is half a pound of fillet and a quarter pound of mushrooms each. Portions that in no way could be considered excessive.KillerB wrote: It should also be noted that six of us got through a 6lb box of mushrooms to go with the 6lb fillet of beef.
"The first duty of Port is to be red"
Ernest H. Cockburn
Ernest H. Cockburn
-
- Taylor’s LBV
- Posts: 152
- Joined: 14:19 Sun 14 Oct 2007
- Location: Bolton England
- uncle tom
- Dalva Golden White Colheita 1952
- Posts: 3532
- Joined: 23:43 Wed 20 Jun 2007
- Location: Near Saffron Walden, England
How DID we get through all those mushrooms??
Tom
PS: It was admitted last year that the 'units' system for alcohol consumption has no scientific basis whatsoever. It was no more than 'inspired guesswork'.
Tom
PS: It was admitted last year that the 'units' system for alcohol consumption has no scientific basis whatsoever. It was no more than 'inspired guesswork'.
I may be drunk, Miss, but in the morning I shall be sober and you will still be ugly - W.S. Churchill
-
- Quinta do Vesuvio 1994
- Posts: 3035
- Joined: 22:16 Mon 25 Jun 2007
- Location: Los Angeles, Ca USA
- Contact:
-
- Taylor’s LBV
- Posts: 152
- Joined: 14:19 Sun 14 Oct 2007
- Location: Bolton England
1980 horizontal: review
I hope that comments are not being delayed just so that some other publication with a longer lead time gets an exclusive. This audience wants timely reportage.Conky wrote:Are we getting close to a summary of events, and maybe some pictures?
Alex kindly provided for lunch a pork pie. New York lacks pork pies, so I really miss them. Then an afternoon nap. I declined the beer, and whilst others had a preliminary pint, with Axel heated the BBQ.
A fantastic steak. Filet. Sampled uncooked, clearly great meat which needed no cooking at all. Alex K and I had the rarest, others requiring a little more heat. With chips, and something else I have forgotten.
So, on to the most blind tasting I have ever attended (thus I have learnt how to organise that such that not even the organiser knows which is which). 1980 is a most muddled vintage. Great names like Nacional and Fonseca made middling port, whilst Ferreira and Offley made stonking good drinks. Very educational.
Tom Archer fell asleep at the table, and when woken by a camera flash, was persuaded to retire. AHB and I were still drinking at dawn, the former managing to wake by 7am. Crack of noon for me.
There was also an entertaining snafu with the placemats
There was also an entertaining snafu with the placemats. They had been printed double-sided: not quite obvious how that would work. So at the last moment a new set, with numbers up to 14 rather than 11, on A4, and single-sided, were made and printed.